Slideshow image

By the rivers of Babylon, we sat down and wept. These ancient words from Psalm 137 echo through centuries, carrying within them a truth many of us are reluctant to admit: sometimes life breaks us so completely that we cannot sing.

The Pressure to Perform

In our modern world, we're constantly bombarded with mantras about positive thinking and projecting confidence. "Fake it till you make it" has become the unofficial gospel of success, encouraging us to wear masks of happiness even when our hearts are breaking. We scroll through social media feeds filled with curated perfection, where everyone appears to have it all together.

But what happens when we can't maintain the facade anymore? What happens when the gap between who we're pretending to be and who we actually are becomes too wide to bridge?

The ancient philosophy of stoicism offers a different path—one that emphasizes virtue, honesty, and integrity over false appearances. Rather than pretending to be something we're not, stoicism invites us to recognize the difference between what we can control (our thoughts, actions, and judgments) and what we cannot control (other people's opinions, external events). This ancient wisdom aligns remarkably well with the apostle Paul's words in Romans 12:2: "Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind."

The Truth That Sets Us Free

Our emotions were given to us by God, and they serve vital purposes in our lives. Positive emotions like joy and gratitude boost our well-being. Fear alerts us to threats and prepares us for action. Sadness connects us with others in moments of loss. Even anger, when properly channeled, can motivate us toward justice and change.

Yet we live in a culture that often demands we suppress our difficult emotions, that we put on a happy face regardless of our internal reality. We're told we're "too emotional" or reminded that we're Christians who should always rejoice. But emotional honesty isn't the opposite of faith—it's the foundation of authentic spirituality.

Psalm 137 stands as one of the Bible's most emotionally raw expressions. It doesn't hide behind religious platitudes or spiritual-sounding phrases. Instead, it captures the devastating grief of the Hebrew people during their Babylonian exile with unflinching honesty.

Songs in Strange Lands

The psalm begins with a haunting scene: captive Israelites sitting by foreign rivers, weeping as they remember their homeland. Jerusalem has been destroyed, the temple razed, loved ones killed. They've been forcibly marched to Babylon, where they will serve as slaves to the very people who devastated their lives.

Their captors, exhibiting the cruel mockery typical of oppressors throughout history, demand entertainment: "Sing us one of the songs of Zion!" They want a performance, a show, a melody to lift their jaded hearts. But how can the Israelites sing songs of joy in a land of sorrow? How can they perform happiness when their hearts are shattered?

This dynamic—the powerful demanding that the powerless perform contentment—echoes throughout history. African slaves in America were expected to sing in the cotton fields, with white slave owners believing that singing indicated contentment and increased productivity. But the enslaved people transformed this demand into something their oppressors couldn't comprehend: they used songs to communicate secret messages, to build solidarity, to express their longing for freedom in coded language.

Frederick Douglass observed that slaves often sang most when they were most unhappy, using songs to express emotions and relieve sorrow. Their music became both a survival tool and a form of resistance.

Holding Space for Grief

The Israelites' response to their captors' demand is profound: they hung up their harps. They refused to pretend. They wouldn't sing songs they didn't feel or perform joy that wasn't genuine. Their silence became a testimony to the depth of their sorrow and the reality of their exile.

Ecclesiastes 3:4 reminds us that there is "a time to weep and a time to laugh, a time to mourn and a time to dance." Life has seasons, and not all seasons call for celebration. Sometimes the most faithful response is simply to acknowledge where we are, to sit with our pain rather than rushing past it.

This is what it means to hold space—for ourselves and for others. It's the gift of allowing grief to exist without judgment, without pressure to "get over it" or "move on." It's refusing to tell someone to pull themselves up by their bootstraps when they don't even have shoes.

The Uncomfortable Ending

The psalm's conclusion is deeply unsettling. After expressing grief and longing, it ends with a cry for vengeance: "Happy shall they be who take your little ones and dash them against the rocks." These words make us shudder. They force us to confront the raw reality of human pain and the dangerous places our emotions can lead us.

How do we reconcile this with Jesus' teachings to love our enemies, turn the other cheek, and pray for those who persecute us? Perhaps the answer lies not in reconciliation but in recognition—the Bible doesn't shy away from the full range of human emotion, even the darkest impulses of rage and revenge.

The scripture doesn't call us to superficial spiritual existence. Instead, it gives us words to speak our tears and pray our pain. It allows us to bring our deepest hurts, our righteous indignations, even our desire for revenge, honestly before God. After all, if God truly knows everything, why would we pretend?

 Hanging Up Our Harps

The Israelites couldn't sing in their strange land, so they hung up their harps. Notice they didn't throw them away, burn them, or sell them. They hung them up—a temporary setting aside, not a permanent abandonment.

They hung up their harps until the chains were broken, until they returned to their homeland, until the weeping ended, until death turned into life and despair into hope and darkness into light. They hung them up because they knew that a day would come when they could take them down and sing again.

This is the hope embedded in even the darkest psalm: silence is not the final word. Grief is not the end of the story. Even in our Babylon, even in our exile, even when God seems silent, the harps remain—waiting for the day when we can sing again.

The question isn't whether we'll face times when we cannot sing. We will. The question is whether we'll have the courage to be honest about it, to refuse the pressure to perform, to hang up our harps rather than play songs we don't feel. And whether we'll hold onto the hope that one day, when the time is right, we'll take them down again.